Skip to content
404 - terrorism site not found

After Charlie Hebdo killings, EU floats terrorism site reporting (again)

Ministers allude to the dead-on-arrival CleanIT project, which ended in 2013.

Cyrus Farivar | 56

In the wake of the recent terrorist attacks on French satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo, a number of European Union ministers have called for a new online tool that would enable “swift reporting of material that aims to incite hatred and terror and the condition of its removing, where appropriate/possible.”

How exactly would this reporting take place? European officials don’t explain in their three-page Sunday statement, but one of the signatories was Gilles de Kerchove, the EU's Counter-Terrorism Coordinator.

The Belgian official endorsed a 2013 quixotic EU-funded plan called CleanIT, which spent €400,000 ($473,000) to hold a bunch of meetings and produce a final report without creating anything concrete. And while CleanIT is not mentioned by name in the new statement, the reporting description sounds very much like it.

As described on its own website (which hasn’t been updated in nearly two years), the CleanIT project wanted to develop a flagging system for “terrorist” content. It wouldn't be mandatory, but Internet providers would be encouraged to take down or block the flagged material. The aim was to create “a non-legislative 'framework' that consists of general principles and best practices… to counter the illegal use of Internet.”

That left obvious questions: who is a terrorist? What's a terrorist website? Would there be an appeal process? No one was really sure with CleanIT, and the new plan being outlined leaves out those details for now, too.

Even if all the debates about speech and law can be worked out, there are practical concerns with a reporting mechanism. What happens if a banned site simply moves its hosting outside the European Union—to Switzerland, Iceland, Serbia, Russia, Turkey, or even farther afield, to the United States or Japan? As an example, the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan’s site is hosted in Russia (as of October 2014), which would be untouchable under this scheme.

Ars' Monday e-mail to But Klaasen, the Dutch national coordinator for counterterrorism and security who headed the CleanIT project, bounced back. If we can contact someone from the old project to comment on this new proposal or the similarities between the two projects, we will update this post.

Photo of Cyrus Farivar
Cyrus Farivar Editor at Large
Cyrus is a former Senior Tech Policy Reporter at Ars Technica, and is also a radio producer and author. His latest book, Habeas Data, about the legal cases over the last 50 years that have had an outsized impact on surveillance and privacy law in America, is out now from Melville House. He is based in Oakland, California.
56 Comments